Small Fracking Earthquakes in Western Pennsylvania Confirmed

by Duane Nichols on February 21, 2017

Fracking caused small earthquakes in western Pennsylvania, PA-DEP confirms

From an Article by Dennis Owens, ABC News (WHTM – Harrisburg), February 17, 2017

The Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection made a big announcement Friday via an online webinar. “The Lawrence County event is properly classified as an induced tectonic seismic event,” droned an unseen scientist.

It was a webinar that only a geologist could love. Lots of science talk, geology terms and slides. There were no faces to be found. But we found the guy behind the Power Point and drilled down for a translation, in English.

“We found a connection between oil and gas activities and these detected seismic events, essentially earthquakes,” explained Seth Pelepko, a geologist who’s also in the DEP’s Oil and Gas program as the Chief of Well Plugging.

The report found that last April in Lawrence County near the Ohio border, five small earthquakes were caused by hydraulic fracturing or fracking in the Utica shale which is deeper than the more frequently mentioned Marcellus shale.

The DEP found that those earthquakes were the equivalent of a lightning strike, that they were caused by a very specific type of drilling in a very specific spot of instability. “There’s multiple contributing factors and they almost have to arrive in a certain combination to trigger an event,” Pelepko said.

The earthquakes are the first in Pennsylvania linked to drilling. The industry points out that there are more than 7,000 well statewide that have been drilled without incident. In a statement, it called the quakes, “isolated and exceptionally rare.”

But environmental group, Sierra Club PA, sees it differently.

“It’s the kind of activity that should not be allowed to move forward at this point because we know that it’s not safe,” Joanne Kilgour, Director of Sierra Club PA chapter, said.

The club typically opposes fracking because it believes fracking endangers drinking water, and now causes earthquakes. “It’s one more evidence that fracking poses threats to our communities,” Kilgour said. “We need to think very seriously about the kind of energy future that we want here in Pennsylvania.”

But fracking and natural gas drilling has been a fiscal geyser, so it’s not going anywhere anytime soon. Nor should it, says the DEP, which has increased its earthquake detection and is insisting keeping a close eye on drillers.

“I think the average person shouldn’t be concerned about this,” Pelepko said.

The five earthquakes were small, around 2.0 on the Richter scale, too small to be felt by people standing on the surface and only registering on seismometers.


Fracking Earthquakes Confirmed in Penna.

Fracking Earthquakes in Pennsylvania

From an Article by David Pacchioli, Penn State University News, January 25, 2017

Last summer, with funding from the state Department of Conservation and Natural Resources, a Penn State team led by geophysicist Andrew Nyblade completed a major expansion of the Pennsylvania Seismic Monitoring Network, creating a system of 30 seismic stations spread across the Commonwealth. Located at Penn State campuses and state parks, the stations contain state-of-the-art ground motion sensors and GPS clocks. The added coverage provides for much more uniform seismic monitoring than was possible before.

Photo: Seismograph traces due to blasting activity look very different from those due to earthquakes (shown above).

Why do we need an expanded seismic monitoring network in Pennsylvania?

There are three reasons. One is that there are areas of natural seismicity in Pennsylvania—one in the Lancaster-Reading area, where there have been magnitude 4 earthquakes, and the other just south of Lake Erie on the Pennsylvania-Ohio border. The largest earthquake yet recorded in Pennsylvania was the Pymatuning earthquake of 1998, just south of Erie. That was a 5.2 magnitude event. When you get to magnitude 4 and 5 events, they can be felt, and they have potential to cause damage to structures, so we need to better understand those zones of seismicity.

Then there are the reasons related to oil and gas activities—induced seismicity, possibly by fracking and more probably by wastewater disposal.

How much seismic monitoring has been done here before, and what did it find?

In 2013-14 we were able to take advantage of a temporary array of seismic stations, part of the NSF EarthScope project, to get a good baseline read on seismicity within the state. What we found was that over 99 percent of the seismic activity in the state actually comes from blasting. There is blasting in coal mines and quarries going on all the time, and some of those blasts are equivalent to magnitude 2, 2.5 earthquakes. So there’s all this background seismic activity, and we need to be able to detect and locate those events so that we can discriminate between them and anything else that might be happening.

Are fracking-related earthquakes a real possibility in Pennsylvania?

We don’t yet know for sure, but Pennsylvania may have had its first fracking-induced seismicity already. In late April [2016], we had a series of seismic events in Lawrence County, near the Ohio border, that have been correlated with a well that was being fracked there.

The bigger concern, though, is with seismicity that’s induced from wastewater disposal. The flowback waters from fracked wells, and also the wastewater that comes from conventional oil and gas wells, has to be disposed of, and a common practice is to pump it back into the ground.  There’s been a huge ramp-up of seismicity in places in Oklahoma, Kansas, Texas, and some places in Canada, and most of that is related to wastewater disposal, not to fracking itself.

Would it be possible that any induced activity would be on a par with natural earthquakes that have been recorded in the state?

Yes. In Oklahoma there have been events induced by wastewater injection that were 5.7, 5.8 magnitude. Magnitude 4s have been recorded in Arkansas and Texas related to wastewater injection. The largest fracking-related events reported so far are magnitude 4s, and those have been in Canada. So there is potential for magnitude 4s and 5s—potentially damaging earthquakes—that could be induced by either fracking or wastewater disposal.

Is there something we can do to mitigate the concern?

Absolutely. As we monitor seismicity across the state, we can detect small events when they happen and determine if they are related to fracking or to wastewater disposal, and if so notify the Department of Environmental Protection, who can then ask the well operator to shut down or take other steps. That’s one of the main purposes of the network, to be able to detect events before they get too large, so that the state authorities can take remedial action.

>>> Andrew Nyblade, professor of geosciences, studies seismology and tectonics in Africa, Antarctica, and North America. He is co-director of the Marcellus Center for Outreach and Research.

>>> This interview first appeared in the Fall 2016 issue of Research/Penn State magazine.


Let’s Look for Wisdom on Presidents’ Day (and everyday)

by Duane Nichols on February 20, 2017

Washington Monument (555 feet high)

George Washington Quotes For Presidents Day

This Holiday Was Originally In Honor Of Washington’s Birthday

Nearly two and a half centuries ago, George Washington became the first President of the United States. To help commemorate the man behind the chopping of the cherry tree, I’ve collected 13 of the best George Washington quotes for Presidents Day.

These quotes cover a lot of territory. From the topics of happiness and labor to freedom of speech and discipline, it seems that George Washington had quite a few things to say. This man’s words are simple yet striking, and it’s apparent from reading over these quotes that he was way ahead of his time in so many ways.

While Presidents Day is meant to commemorate all of the United States’ Presidents, it specifically falls in February because of George Washington’s birthday, so it only seems appropriate to give the guy a bit more attention than the rest this Feb. 20.

Be sure to set aside some time today to reflect on America’s history and the many men who first helped to lead this country. If you’re really feeling inspired, share a quote or two with your friends and family via social media. George Washington may have never known what Facebook or Twitter are, but that doesn’t have to stop his influence from being shared on their platforms.

1. “If freedom of speech is taken away, then dumb and silent we may be led, like sheep to the slaughter.”

2. “The Constitution is the guide which I never will abandon.”

3. “Happiness and moral duty are inseparably connected.”

4. “It is far better to be alone, than to be in bad company.”

5. “Labor to keep alive in your breast that little spark of celestial fire, called conscience.”

6. “Associate with men of good quality if you esteem your own reputation; for it is better to be alone than in bad company.”

7. “I had rather be on my farm than be emperor of the world.”

8. “Observe good faith and justice toward all nations. Cultivate peace and harmony with all.”

9. “Discipline is the soul of an army. It makes small numbers formidable; procures success to the weak, and esteem to all.”

10. “To be prepared for war is one of the most effective means of preserving peace.”

11. “Arbitrary power is most easily established on the ruins of liberty abused to licentiousness.”

12. “Let us raise a standard to which the wise and honest can repair; the rest is in the hands of God.”

13. “Guard against the impostures of pretended patriotism.”


{ 1 comment }

Pipelines Issues with ACP & MVP in our National Forests

February 19, 2017

Atlantic Coast Pipeline — Action to Support our National Forest We need your help to protect one of the wildest, most intact forests in the East. Dominion’s proposed 600-mile Atlantic Coast Pipeline would cross 21 miles of the George Washington and Monongahela National Forests. Ask the Forest Service to reject Dominion’s efforts to shortcut the [...]

Read the full article →

Letter of Concern to WV-DEP and the WV Governor

February 18, 2017

Open Letter to Gov. Jim Justice and DEP Sec. Austin Caperton TO: Jim Justice & Austin Caperton. From: Tom Bond, Lewis County   How is the air down there in Charleston?  Still clean?  Do you plan to move out into the country near some of the new Marcellus drilling industry?  Maybe near a compressor station [...]

Read the full article →

Attention Citizens: Scott Pruitt Required to Release Emails

February 17, 2017

Senate Confirms Scott Pruitt to Head Environmental Protection Agency 52 – 46 From an Article by Leigh Ann Caldwell, NBC News, February 17, 2017 The U.S. Senate Friday confirmed Oklahoma attorney General Scott Pruitt to head the EPA in a party-line 52-46 vote. Democrats did all they could to delay the final vote, holding another [...]

Read the full article →

Atmospheric Methane Continues to Increase in Marcellus Region

February 16, 2017

Methane has Increased in Marcellus Shale Region Despite  Dip in Gas Well Installations Media Contact:  Britt Faulstick, Drexel University, February 10, 2017 Drexel researchers have been studying air pollution in the Marcellus Shale regions of Pennsylvania for several years.  Despite a slow down in the number of new natural gas wells in the Marcellus Shale region [...]

Read the full article →

Zombie Bills are Back in the WV State Legislature

February 15, 2017

Zombie Bills: Bills to Aid Drillers Are Back From an Article by  Julie Archer, WVSORO, February 11, 2017 As we anticipated, some bad bills that aid drillers at the expense of West Virginia landowners — bills that were either soundly defeated or stalled at different points in the legislative process in 2016 — are starting to [...]

Read the full article →

Part 3. WV Residents Will Not Get Protection from Compressor Station Noise & Lights

February 14, 2017

  ‘G-35-D posted on the website Monday, January 30, 2017’ From an Article by Ken Ward, Jr., Charleston Gazette-Mail, February 11, 2017 During a series of interviews before he left the WV-DEP last month, Randy Huffman talked about his belief that the agency needed to continue to do more to help address the on-the-ground effects of [...]

Read the full article →

Part 2: WV Residents Will Not Get Protection from Compressor Station Noise & Lights

February 13, 2017

‘Better and better and better and better’ From an Article by Ken Ward, Jr., Charleston Gazette-Mail, February 11, 2017 Commenting in his speech about the state’s natural gas industry, Justice said, “We need to do everything we can to exploit that to make it even better and better and better and better.” The governor also [...]

Read the full article →

WV Residents Will Not Get Protection from Compressor Station Noise & Lights

February 12, 2017

WV-DEP eliminates protections for noise, light from natural gas facilities From an Article by Ken Ward, Jr., Charleston Gazette-Mail, February 11, 2017 Less than two weeks after taking office, Gov. Jim Justice’s administration quietly deleted permit language intended to protect residents in West Virginia’s natural gas regions from excessive noise and bright lights from compressor [...]

Read the full article →